Login  |  Search

CHRUSP mission - and "forced electroshock" or "electroshock"

CHRUSP mission - and "forced electroshock" or "electroshock"
Tina Minkowitz - Wed Aug 11, 2010 @ 11:02AM
Comments: 24

We have made a slight change in our mission statement, saying that we work for an end to "forced drugging, forced electroshock and psychiatric incarceration." It used to say "forced drugging, electroshock and psychiatric incarceration". A supporter asked us to clarify the ambiguity.

Our original intention was to address forced psychiatry of any kind and to also address the need to change from a medical model to social/spiritual/personal model by promoting the kinds of support people want.

I have heard respected advocates against electroshock offer different reasons for opposing it entirely. One reason is that "it is not possible to have free and informed consent to electroshock." Another is that it is simply too harmful, too brain-damaging and there are alternatives. I am open to hearing from you about what you think on this issue and would reopen the question of whether CHRUSP should oppose all electroshock based on your comments.

If we oppose electroshock, should we similarly oppose neuroleptic drugs? There are people who have had seriously traumatic brain-damaging effects from the use of neuroleptics. And we know that there is little if any free and informed consent for these drugs either. So long as there is a threat of coercion, discrimination and pressure from families, courts and society to numb and repress our feelings, so long as alternatives are few and far between, so long as doctors minimize and dismiss the serious adverse effects - consent to psychiatric drugs of any kind is neither free nor informed.

I would like to know the views of CHRUSP friends and supporters on where you draw the line between acceptable and unacceptable treatments, services and supports - those that should be promoted, those that should be allowed with free and informed consent, and those that should be opposed under any circumstances. And on what basis you make the distinctions. Personal experience is very relevant. And by putting this in categories or a logical framework I don't mean to repress your creativity in responding. The purpose is to think about what position we should advocate in CHRUSP and hopefully to feed a more general discussion on this topic in the user/survivor movement as a whole.

 

Comments: 24

Comments

1. Kent Reedy   |   Mon Dec 27, 2010 @ 11:48AM

There will always be some people who say they benefitted from electroshock, and some will say so very adamently and to a very large audience (e.g. Kitty Dukakis). So I think it is definitely better to just be against electroshock that is forced or coerced rather than all electroshock -- it is much harder for anyone to credibly accuse you of taking away their right to a beneficial treatment that way. I think it is mostly the role of the dominant powers to prevent people from having access to something that might harm them -- dissenters can be most effective by only supporting the right to not be harmed by someone else.

Even if it is true that "it is not possible to have free and informed consent to electroshock", I don't think there is any chance that it will ever be totally abolished until it is first not allowed to ever be given forcibly. But I think there should be more liability for the people who give ECT to have to compensate the people they shocked for the damage that results, even if electroshock was consented to.

The same should be true for the drugs as well -- the people who give them should be held personally liable for whatever damage they cause, even when the person taking them didn't object. Some people do take the drugs willingly, but they should still be able to collect some kind of compensation when the drugs do terrible things to them.

If psychiatrists were held more to account for the provable physical damage that they routinely cause, then I think they would do a lot less of it.

2. dresses  |  my website   |   Thu Mar 03, 2011 @ 01:06AM

Some people do take the drugs willingly, but they should still be able to collect some kind of compensation when the drugs do terrible things to them.

3. Nike Shox TL1 Shoes  |  my website   |   Mon Nov 07, 2011 @ 01:23AM

I follow threads and blogs.Love to post and comments.There are lot of stuff of me and hoping to receive as well from <a href="http://www.donikeshox-shoes.info" title="Cheap Nike Shox Shoes">Cheap Nike Shox Shoes</a>. Thanks for sharing your article,it's very nice,thanks. I hope can read more good articles about <a href="http://www.donikeshox-shoes.info" title="Cheap Nike Shox Shoes">Cheap Nike Shox Shoes</a>. I just stumbled upon your blog and wanted to say that I have really enjoyed browsing your blog posts about <a href="http://www.coachfactorystore.ca" title="Coach Outlet Canada">Coach Outlet Canada</a>. And we are sure you woule be surprised with <a href="http://www.jumpman23footwear.com" title="cheap jordans for sale">cheap jordans for sale</a>. There ar so much educational information on <a href="http://www.ugg-boots-outlet-factory.net" title="Cheap Ugg">Cheap Ugg</a>.And we are sure it would be more funny articles here.

4. seo services  |  my website   |   Fri Jan 10, 2014 @ 01:23AM

seo services company in india

5. Albert   |   Mon May 11, 2015 @ 01:37AM

For clarifying your mission and idea you used words like that which hits people psychologically and that is an awesome technique to make realize people the importance of something. www.getessaydone.com we shall also teach such techniques to our students for which we can take help from your site.

6. johnny   |   Tue Sep 22, 2015 @ 03:22AM
7. khalifa   |   Tue Sep 22, 2015 @ 03:12AM
8. alvin   |   Tue Sep 22, 2015 @ 04:08AM

It depends on you how you draft acceptable and unacceptable terms.You now better what kind of support people want by your side and you deliver them. It's a good step of changing in your mission. Our www.helpdohomework.com/ also provide assistance where students needed.

9. Anonymous   |   Tue Dec 08, 2015 @ 09:59AM

I thought you people preferred to use these essay online reviews. Everyone must try to entertain the college essay editors and www.researchpaperservicesreviews.com blog editors. So, I am very happy to take this opportunity for our college students.

10. Smith   |   Wed Jan 13, 2016 @ 02:49AM

Yes this is really great informative post and i appreciate your work because "forced electroshock" or "electroshock" really great point your discuss in your post. For sale our playground tiles visit our site http://playgroundtilesuk.co.uk/

13. Angelina Jukić  |  my website   |   Mon Apr 04, 2016 @ 05:05PM

Hi there
I read you blogpost. Really nice post Thanks for sharing this types post.Keep it up.
The best thing about handling cases in a small claim tribunal is the fact that the process involved is fast and affordable. You do not need an attorney as you have the right to represent yourself.For getting help contact with them.To follow below-

Thanks
Angelina Jukic

14. alan   |   Mon Jun 06, 2016 @ 08:25AM

Nice article for all readers. Thanks for sharing this great post with us.
<a href="http://www.examcollection.us/HP0-S42-vce.html">HP0-S42 vce</a>

15. Google  |  my website   |   Thu Jun 23, 2016 @ 12:02AM

This is a good post. This post gives truly quality information. I'm definitely going to look into it. Really very useful tips are provided here.

16. online denim shirts Pakistan  |  my website   |   Tue Feb 14, 2017 @ 03:38AM

I definitely enjoying every little bit of it. It is a great website and nice share. I want to thank you. Good job! You guys do a great blog, and have some great contents. Keep up the good work.
<a href='https://goo.gl/2BSQVN'>online denim shirts Pakistan</a>

17. fashion magazines  |  my website   |   Thu Feb 16, 2017 @ 05:56AM

I found your this post while searching for information about blog-related research ... It's a good post .. keep posting and updating information.

18. showbox movies  |  my website   |   Mon Mar 06, 2017 @ 03:42AM
19. osama  |  my website   |   Tue Apr 11, 2017 @ 09:36AM

Awesome content for all visitors. Thanks for discussing this excellent publish with us<a href="https://www.google.com/">google</a>.

20. Best Gaming Monitors   |   Sat Jun 03, 2017 @ 08:23AM

In this Turtle Beach PX5 review (as well as the video review below), you’re going to learn all about this top of the line gaming headset for PS3. Turtle Beach has created quite a reputation for producing quality headsets gamers love to use. http://germanposada.com/?p=2757

21. mobogenie app download   |   Wed Jun 21, 2017 @ 02:33AM

Whenever you use the Google play store to download new applications or update existing ones, don’t you get haunted by the question why only Play store? and not any other? https://baixarmobogenieapk.com/

22. tubemate app for iphone   |   Sat Jul 01, 2017 @ 05:41AM

One the main problem that most of the people are facing is that for downloading YouTube videos we just can’t download YouTube videos without any downloader. http://itubeappapk.org/download-tubemate-app-iphone-ipad/

23. download whatsapp plus   |   Thu Jul 20, 2017 @ 08:12AM

WhatsApp diplomat is a best messaging application for PDA customers. This application uses Internet to send texts, pictures, video, reports, and sound messages http://plusapk.kinja.com/whatsapp-plus-apk-1796943719?rev=1500101754278

24. TubeMate Apk   |   Wed Aug 23, 2017 @ 02:14AM

Are you looking for an app with which you can download videos from YouTube without any complications and less trouble? You have visited the right place https://itubeappapk.org/tubemate-apk-2-2-6-download-android-smartphone/

Post a Comment