Login  |  Search

Co-optation

Co-optation
Tina Minkowitz - Fri Dec 09, 2011 @ 08:05AM
Comments: 281

The first phase of co-optation I experienced in the anti-psychiatric abuse movement was in 1985.  I was not a very active member or leader at that time, but I went to the annual "International Conference For Human Rights and Against Psychiatric Oppression" in 1985 and experienced the three-way division that left the North American movement, at least, in a weakened and demoralized state.  This division may have also allowed NAMI, an organization of family members that at the national level receives most of its funding from pharmaceutical companies and is pro-forced psychiatry, to emerge as the voice of "mental health advocacy" sought out by the media.  

The 1985 co-optation was brought about by government mental health agencies in the U.S. negotiating to fund a consumer movement that would co-operate with, rather than oppose, the mental health system.  Before 1985 the groups I knew about met in people's houses and in public spaces, and on rare occasions received funding to open a drop-in center and house where people could stay.  We held our conferences at a university campus when school was not in session, not in fancy hotels.  From that time till today, developments have been such that most of our movement is dependent on funding from the mental health system.  Some organizations use the funding creatively and even find that, by refusing to "pre-emptively comply" with onerous conditions, they can do much more than they might have thought possible.  

The Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities (a UN human rights treaty, on which I worked as a representative of the World Network of Users and Survivors of Psychiatry) represented, to me, in part a way to break through the stagnation in the movement, particularly the way that talk about abolition of psychiatric incarceration and forced interventions had been stifled by government money.  Most likely I would not have expressed it that way at the time, but I saw an opening in human rights and the lens of non-discrimination that allowed us to say "we have been left outside looking in, now we claim a place at the table and redefine what's on the menu."  This was helped greatly by the fact that we came in as part of the disability community which had politicized its own involvement in an earlier UN process so that the slogan "Nothing about us without us" was a rallying cry that made sense to governments as well as non-governmental organizations.

Since the adoption and entry into force of the CRPD, a new co-optation is happening that I had not anticipated.  I should say at the outset that the mental health system co-optation is also continuing on the world level, with WHO and its supporters sponsoring "human rights" training and manuals that accept the practice of forced psychiatry, and promoting alliances of user/survivor organizations with mental health agencies based on this same premise.  But the co-optation is not limited to the mental health system this time.

The International Disability Alliance has been converted from a coalition of equal partners in which each member had a veto over activities or positions that did not reflect its own positions, to an agency run by non-disabled people (executive director and other key positions) primarily from the global north that "works in" countries in the global south and claims to represent the global community of people with disabilities at the UN.  WNUSP, a member of IDA, no longer has the power to collaborate with its colleagues (the other global organizations of people with disabilities and regional federations of disability organizations that are the members of IDA) to create mutually agreed agendas and carry out work together.  Instead, the work is proposed by the executive director, approved by the IDA members as a "governing body", and then carried out by the secretariat, at times with token participation by the representatives of IDA member organizations. 

Human rights organizations, including those dealing specifically with the rights of people with "mental" disabilities, and development organizations, saw the opportunities for their own growth and development of their work.  While we were regrouping after the exhausting and exhilarating task of creating the CRPD, these organizations took advantage of the new treaty to continue on in their old work that was based on faulty standards, particularly the now discredited and superseded Principles for the Protection of Persons with Mental Illness (see Torture Rapporteur Report A/63/175, paragraph 44, and OHCHR Legal Measures Study A/HRC/10/48, paragraphs 48-49, acknowledging the MI principles superseded by the CRPD).  Funders also approached these organizations practically begging them to get involved, despite at least my own voice cautioning funders that they should insist that such organizations partner with organizations of people with disabilities who have the policy expertise and authenticity to drive CRPD implementation and monitoring just as we created the treaty itself.  (At least one organization is playing a token game, repeatedly inviting us to join in their agenda and ignoring our requests for honest dialogue and acknowledgement of our leadership.)

One phenomenon happening in all the international co-optation post-CRPD adoption, is the bypassing of WNUSP, the global organization of users and survivors of psychiatry/ people with psychosocial disabilities, with funders, human rights organizations, WHO and IDA secretariat seeking to have a direct relationship with national user/survivor organizations to provide them with training on the CRPD.  This is disrespectful and not in keeping with the principle of "nothing about us without us," and gives the impression that we are not the suppliers of expertise but only the recipients of training by experts whose lack of lived experience seems to give them greater credibility.  These agencies, all based in the global north, also appear to want to "protect" user/survivor organizations in the global south from the influence of leaders in the worldwide movement who are opposed to forced psychiatry.  They seem to think that wanting freedom from oppression is a conspiracy of outside agitators - sound familiar?  

Our movement has been slow (from my perspective) to understand the potential of the CRPD much less to be willing to believe in yet another promise that may remain unfulfilled.  There has already been a lot of co-optation worldwide, so that those of us who want our national and local organizations to work for abolition of forced psychiatry have to deal with funders, non-user/survivor staff who usurp decision-making power, and members who are peace-loving and traumatized people reluctant to be in the middle of ideological wars.  Despite all this it is happening, and user/survivor organizations everywhere are taking the CRPD and making it their own, adapting the message of freedom and self-determination to their own circumstances and speaking in the many authentic voices of our movement.

I feel sorrow and grief over the co-optation that has happened in relation to work in which I was personally involved.  Yet I see the results of my work not only in the user/survivor movement taking up the CRPD standards, but also in the fact that many of those who fought me at one time or another end up adopting the positions and strategies I have advocated.  I would rather the co-optation not be happening, as it drains energy and puts additional obstacles in our path.  My hope is that we can defeat co-optation by naming it and coming together to cooperate for our freedom and for the solidarity to meet our human needs.  The CRPD gives us a chance to develop policies appropriate to the society we live in, to play a role in governance responsible to the society as a whole.  (I mean that we have an opening to put forward serious, comprehensive policies for laws and programs that reflect what we truly want.  It is similar, I think, to what happens after a revolution when the revolutionaries have to govern.)  As I have been arguing elsewhere, I believe we have the tools, models and skills to shape such policy.  Watch for further discussions and let me know what you think.  

The "growing up" of a movement does not have to mean co-optation, rather co-optation is a challenge that a movement has to face in its "growing up." 

Comments: 281

Comments

151. Leonardo36  |  my website   |   Thu Sep 25, 2014 @ 09:04AM

I’m very fired up to show it to anyone. It makes me so satisfied your vast understanding and wisdom have a new channel for trying into the world.

152. Hologram projection   |   Sat Sep 27, 2014 @ 08:53AM

Thanks for nnice sharing
http://www.resumes-planets.net

153. Morgan201  |  my website   |   Mon Sep 29, 2014 @ 09:50AM

This is really a amazing post. I couldn't have asked for a much better post than this. I am literally very pleased with this and I just hope that I will keep on getting such amazing posts!

154. Morgan201  |  my website   |   Mon Sep 29, 2014 @ 09:44AM

This is really a amazing post. I couldn't have asked for a much better post than this. I am literally very pleased with this and I just hope that I will keep on getting such amazing posts!

155. Thesis writing service in UAE  |  my website   |   Fri Oct 03, 2014 @ 07:28AM

Thank the author for this marvelous efforts. I appreciate your efforts in preparing this post..

156. Nursing Essay Writing Service  |  my website   |   Mon Oct 13, 2014 @ 05:59AM

It seems to collect a lot of different ideas in the Word document. I do it in different sheets of paper in my notebook. You have what you do now?
<a href="http://www.britishessayshelp.co.uk/nursing-essay.php">nursing essay writing service</a>

157. writing essayz  |  my website   |   Wed Oct 15, 2014 @ 05:11AM

Thanks for sharing your great work and letting me to say about it.

158. sarwar  |  my website   |   Sat Oct 18, 2014 @ 01:53PM

you did work very well.

159. Nerman4  |  my website   |   Mon Oct 20, 2014 @ 09:01AM

I fit in with your conclusions and will eagerly look forward to your next updates. Just saying thanks will not just be sufficient, for the fantasti c lucidity in your writing. I will instantly grab your rss feed to stay informed of any updates.

160. Nerman4  |  my website   |   Mon Oct 20, 2014 @ 09:11AM

I fit in with your conclusions and will eagerly look forward to your next updates. Just saying thanks will not just be sufficient, for the fantasti c lucidity in your writing. I will instantly grab your rss feed to stay informed of any updates.

161. Jim Garder  |  my website   |   Thu Oct 23, 2014 @ 09:45AM

I just got to this amazing site not long ago.

162. Do My Coursework For Me  |  my website   |   Thu Oct 23, 2014 @ 05:08PM

The author has written an excellent article. You made your point and not much to discuss. Everything has its exception. <a href="http://www.buy-essay.com/do-my-assignment/">Do My Assignment For Me</a> . Thanks for this information. <a href="http://www.buy-essay.com/do-my-coursework/">Do My Coursework</a>

163. Do My Coursework For Me  |  my website   |   Thu Oct 23, 2014 @ 05:09PM

The author has written an excellent article. You made your point and not much to discuss. Everything has its exception. <a href="http://www.buy-essay.com/do-my-assignment/">Do My Assignment For Me</a> . Thanks for this information. <a href="http://www.buy-essay.com/do-my-coursework/">Do My Coursework</a>

164. rggtye   |   Fri Oct 24, 2014 @ 09:06AM

I needed to post you the very small word to say thank you yet again for your unique solutions you've shown here. This is really seriously generous with you to convey unhampered all that a few people could have sold for an electronic book to earn some money on their own, especially considering that you could possibly have done it if you ever desired. The principles as well acted as a great way to recognize that someone else have the same desire much like mine to understand great deal more pertaining to this problem. I am sure there are lots of more pleasurable instances ahead for people who go through your blog.
http://www.bnat-games.com/

165. Bijor45  |  my website   |   Fri Oct 24, 2014 @ 01:39PM

I have read a few of the articles on your website now, and I really like your style. Thanks a million and please keep up the effective work..

166. Bijor45  |  my website   |   Fri Oct 24, 2014 @ 01:41PM

I have read a few of the articles on your website now, and I really like your style. Thanks a million and please keep up the effective work..

167. brain   |   Sat Oct 25, 2014 @ 05:43AM

I think that a lot of of them extremely do care regarding what they see, however they're thus involved, regarding however folks perceive them that they're unlikely to talk up or say something out of hand. They still build terribly tokenistic efforts to vary something in any respect.
<a herf="http://assignmentz.co.uk/">Assignment online</a>

168. Miller56  |  my website   |   Sun Oct 26, 2014 @ 09:43AM

I must spend a while finding out more or understanding more

169. Jim Garder  |  my website   |   Tue Oct 28, 2014 @ 08:33AM

Actually This post is exactly what I am interested. we need some more good information.

170. Mikehelen589  |  my website   |   Wed Nov 05, 2014 @ 08:28AM

I just thought it may be an idea to post incase anyone else was having problems researching but I am a little unsure if I am allowed to put names and addresses on here.

171. Mikehelen589  |  my website   |   Wed Nov 05, 2014 @ 08:30AM

I just thought it may be an idea to post incase anyone else was having problems researching but I am a little unsure if I am allowed to put names and addresses on here.

172. Bill adam  |  my website   |   Thu Nov 13, 2014 @ 06:10AM

This is a good website for Medical billing services visit <a href="http://www.billingconsultancy.com/medical-billing-services/">Medical Billing Services</a> Provides you all the data you need. For Denial management visit <a href="http://www.billingconsultancy.com/denial-management/">Denial Management Services</a> provides you all the information required.

173. Lilian109  |  my website   |   Sat Nov 15, 2014 @ 09:10AM

Thanks for this nice share! You may also like

174. Rachel8129  |  my website   |   Sun Nov 16, 2014 @ 08:08AM

Being that it is the largest of these eliminatory organs, it reflects the internal imbalances of body ecology most apparently. When we see eczema and psoriasis it is the tell tale sign that there is a shift needed inside to make changes to what we eat and how it is assimilated.

175. Denial Management  |  my website   |   Mon Nov 17, 2014 @ 03:32AM

A big thank you for your post.Really looking forward to read more. Really Great.<a href="http://www.billingconsultancy.com/denial-management/">Denial Management Services</a>

176. Denial Management  |  my website   |   Mon Nov 17, 2014 @ 03:35AM

A big thank you for your post.Really looking forward to read more. Really Great.<a href="http://www.billingconsultancy.com/denial-management/">Denial Management Services</a>

177. education management systems  |  my website   |   Sat Nov 22, 2014 @ 01:57AM

Thank you for your post, I look for such article along time, today I find it finally. This post gives me lots of advice it is very useful for me. Nice I like it.

178. Michael45  |  my website   |   Mon Nov 24, 2014 @ 09:09AM

Thanks for sharing this valuable information.

179. check cashing nearer in fresno ca  |  my website   |   Mon Nov 24, 2014 @ 07:48PM

Profit evening improvements different enhancements most likely won't particularly normally work with an unwinding tastefulness regimen, and this means component may be collecting inside the shape the second every individual inconvenience free used in which regularly. You can regularly ensure an advanced fork out inside cost, for example, the specific pay enhance despite the fact that secure where by completely when your individual general installments record emerges. That will aid you recoup an alternate lady's visual perception value others secure, for example, the specific salary enhance, ensure where by considering the essential likelihood, more likely than not preceding may be experienced completely.

180. check cashing nearer in fresno ca  |  my website   |   Mon Nov 24, 2014 @ 07:50PM

Profit evening improvements different enhancements most likely won't particularly normally work with an unwinding tastefulness regimen, and this means component may be collecting inside the shape the second every individual inconvenience free used in which regularly. You can regularly ensure an advanced fork out inside cost, for example, the specific pay enhance despite the fact that secure where by completely when your individual general installments record emerges. That will aid you recoup an alternate lady's visual perception value others secure, for example, the specific salary enhance, ensure where by considering the essential likelihood, more likely than not preceding may be experienced completely.

181. Denial management  |  my website   |   Wed Nov 26, 2014 @ 07:27AM

This is a very informative article.

182. jasa pembuatan website  |  my website   |   Sat Nov 29, 2014 @ 12:41PM

I really appreciate for your brilliant Efforts on spending time to post this information in a simple and systematic manner, so That visitors and readers can easily Understand the concept.I Efforts must appreciate you posting these on information.<a href=http://www.calibreworks.com/jasa-pembuatan-website/>jasa pembuatan website</a>

183. Komana   |   Sat Nov 29, 2014 @ 03:04PM

You can damage hair by blowdrying it. If you must dry your hair with a blow dryer, put it on the cold air function and constantly move the device to ensure it does not remain in one place for too long. http://www.revitolhairremovalcream.co/

184. Denial Management  |  my website   |   Tue Dec 09, 2014 @ 05:23AM

Superb post, little lengthy but full of important information. Keep posting such posts. Great work!!.<a href="http://www.billingconsultancy.com/medical-billing-services/">Medical Billing Services</a>

185. Denial Management  |  my website   |   Tue Dec 09, 2014 @ 05:16AM

Superb post, little lengthy but full of important information. Keep posting such posts.<a href="http://www.billingconsultancy.com/medical-billing-services/">Medical Billing Services</a>

186. Coursework Writing Service  |  my website   |   Tue Dec 09, 2014 @ 06:48AM

All the contents you mentioned in post are too good and can be very useful. I will keep it in mind, thanks for sharing the information keep updating, looking forward for more posts.

187. Dennis301  |  my website   |   Sun Dec 14, 2014 @ 09:46AM

Awesome article.Really looking forward to read more. Keep writing.

188. John654  |  my website   |   Fri Dec 19, 2014 @ 08:12AM

Writing with style and getting good compliments on the article is quite hard, to be honest.But you've done it so calmly and with so cool feeling and you've nailed the job. This article is possessed with style and I am giving good compliment.

189. Daniel46  |  my website   |   Thu Jan 08, 2015 @ 01:33PM

Having a great time reading your blog post. you know what your readers want. Keep posting.

190. Daniel46  |  my website   |   Thu Jan 08, 2015 @ 01:25PM

Having a great time reading your blog post. you know what your readers want. Keep posting.

191. Paulette Dodson  |  my website   |   Tue Feb 10, 2015 @ 02:54AM

This is nice, i been looking for that kinda stuff. you know what a friend of mine was asking me do my assignment for me. topic just like you have done above.. great piece of work http://www.quickcourseworkhelp.co.uk/do-my-coursework.php

192. happy new year 2016  |  my website   |   Mon Feb 23, 2015 @ 05:03PM

I really appreciate for your brilliant Efforts on spending time to post this information in a simple and systematic manner, so That visitors and readers can easily Understand the concept.I Efforts must appreciate you posting these on information.

193. Jack Smith  |  my website   |   Thu Mar 19, 2015 @ 05:11AM

Your this article really amazing with useful information. I learn much more knowledge from here keep posting beautiful articles

194. Jack Smith  |  my website   |   Fri Mar 27, 2015 @ 03:05AM

Your this post full of valuable knowledge thanks for sharing this great post

195. bryanparker   |   Mon Apr 20, 2015 @ 04:50AM

A striking fact of this band is that the drummer’s position was problems efficiently.
http://www.uniofdenton.com/

196. baran better  |  my website   |   Fri Apr 24, 2015 @ 09:57AM

A lifetime be trial 17 stalked 17 guilty at seventeen missing it 17 future I'm not one to it was all about 70 IHeartBreaker fugitive at seventeen and then dead at seventy the best Dec thank you life time I had every TV.

197. Payton  |  my website   |   Fri Jun 19, 2015 @ 04:03AM

L’anniversaire des 10 ans de jumelage entre Laredo et Cenon fut l’occasion d’intensifier les rencontres et les échanges entre les deux villes. <a href="http://plus.google.com/111052320740354695507/posts/Uc7HMqP5BKx" rel="nofollow">!</a>

198. Payton  |  my website   |   Fri Jun 19, 2015 @ 04:05AM

L’anniversaire des 10 ans de jumelage entre Laredo et Cenon fut l’occasion d’intensifier les rencontres et les échanges entre les deux villes. http://plus.google.com/111052320740354695507/posts/Uc7HMqP5BKx

199. Itachi  |  my website   |   Sun Jun 21, 2015 @ 10:46PM

Also, you can keep a free blog dedicated to your genealogical search and update it regularly whenever you http://www.evernote.com/shard/s557/sh/1e4e4698-bfde-48ca-b573-d6577b2a23cb/cc74482d770aa2c29e98751cdd92179b

200. Diana  |  my website   |   Tue Jul 07, 2015 @ 12:01AM

Awesome website you have here but I was wondering if you knew of any discussion boards that cover the same topics talked about in this article? I'd really like to be a part of online community where I can get comments from other experienced people that share the same

Post a Comment